by Onasander on Tue Jul 27, 2010 9:11 pm
Religion yes. We've hardly covered this up. Religion is rites and explanations. They evolve and die out. Religion is remarkably secular in nature. I believe in God, but have little in way of religion. Trinkets. Even the monastic robe is a joke if thought about closely. It was useful in Egypt during the times of the Desert Fathers of the late Roman Empire, when men would enter into the deserts and live in a monastic cell or small community in isolation in the desert. It's survival into the modern age... though it's very easy to understand the why it did so- is still rather silly as a object, a mark of tradition that has little baring on the actual task at hand of the deepening of the spirit and serving god though the aid and inspiration of man. Bluejeans and a collar shirt should work just as well. A apartment as well as a cell. A job as well as gardening or making trappist cheese. But it's a continuation, and it aids in the process for those who desire it, and doesn't perceivable cripple. I shrug my shoulders at it, and accept allowances must be made. I am sure others do the same upon seeing me.
And I think we took much, much more from the Neo-Plotinus movement. Ask a Catholic or Orthodox priest sometime about the Nous. Not all christians, even in the Catholic or Orthodox Church, bother with Platonic or Platonic explanations of philosophy, some choose to take a Taoist approach, or even a Hindu approach in all things that does NOT contradict the scriptures. Catholic church has Hindu style monks in India, near impossible to discern from the local monks, who've taken on every tradition and philosophy that doesn't inherently contradict. Orthodox churches are starting to explore similar options. We never were limited to Greek and Roman ideals, it's not a rule anywhere..... infact, given our Jewish roots that had anti-greek sentiment in the beginning, it's not surprising we're exploring outside it. So long as the essential message remains clear, it's pretty much for the most part is all good. I can only name a few exceptions where Roman or Greek customs dominate- such as in Polygamy (not a real rule- the holy roman emperor Charlemagne had 5 wives, and the Ethiopian church always allowed Polygamy).
